Knowing Roofing Prices: Is Tin Cheaper Than Asphalt Roofing? A number of factors influence the decision to "Is Tin Cheaper Than Asphalt Roofing?" Asphalt shingles are a cost-effective option for initial installation because they are usually less expensive up front. Conversely, tin roofs are more expensive initially but are more durable and energy-efficient. Tin roofs may eventually last longer and require less maintenance, making the upfront cost worthwhile. Asphalt may be the best option for those seeking temporary cost savings. Tin roofing, however, can be a better investment in terms of durability and long-term worth.